lazypadawan: (Default)
lazypadawan ([personal profile] lazypadawan) wrote2004-11-28 08:53 pm

Harry Potter people....

What did you all think of the movie version of The Prisoner of Azkaban?

I rented it last night and watched it with my parents, brother, and his g/f. My mom thought it was all right, everyone else hated it.



Well, I didn't hate it. I think I liked Chamber of Secrets a little bit more, but overall, I'd give it 3 stars. (Note, I'm regarding it as a movie-watcher, not as a fan of the books.)

What I liked:

*A darker, angrier Harry. Finally he's had it with the Dursleys' crap. I also liked how he was willing to bend the rules and kill the ones he thought were responsible for his parents' death. He also has a miss my daddy complex like Luke Skywalker.

*Speaking of Harry, Daniel Radcliffe is growing up to be a handsome young fella. I'll say no more until after he turns 18.

*Hogwarts' cool gothic look.

*The theme of misunderstood outsiders, including Harry, Sirius Black, and that big flying birdlike thing.

*Draco gets his butt kicked. At last. Twice.

*The effects.

*The music.

What was meh:

*Is it just me, or did they make Ron look more foolish?

*The movie slows down significantly in the middle and I found parts of it a little confusing.

[identity profile] foodsthatcan.livejournal.com 2004-11-29 05:44 am (UTC)(link)
DID NOT LIKE the movie x 100000000000. You can look up my comments in my LJ if you want to read the whole shebang of why.

I am seriously considering skipping the fourth movie, just because it's ridiculous of me to continue seeing these films and getting upset at all of them. Also, the books become increasingly difficult to adapt as they progress.

[identity profile] lazypadawan.livejournal.com 2004-11-30 04:18 am (UTC)(link)
I just read your review again. Good point about the stag; that's never explained.

My brother and dad found the film boring and confusing; bro's g/f felt that you probably had to read the book in order to get what was going on. Perhaps because I haven't read any of the HP books and perhaps because my expectations weren't all that high, I wasn't as down on it as they were.